Why Romance in the Harry Potter Movies Doesn’t Work? The Harry Potter franchise has repeatedly demonstrated its popularity. The books were a cultural phenomenon, the films were universally well-received by audiences, and the recently released Hogwarts Legacy broke Twitch viewing records on its first day (according to CNN) and has already outsold last year’s game of the year.
However, as time has passed, cracks have begun to appear in this once-beloved franchise, which has recently been embroiled in controversy, and people have begun to scrutinise the films they once praised so highly.
In addition to the numerous omitted storylines, characters, and odd portrayal of Dumbledore beyond the first two films, many fans have come to realise that the films lack the satisfying love stories that were present in the books.
Despite the fact that romance is still present in films, many believe that the depiction of love falls short of the standards set by literature.
In contrast to the content that was omitted, however, the relationships in the movies were altered rather than eliminated, allowing for a unique analysis of what went wrong by comparing where the two versions of the same story diverge.
To understand where things went wrong, one must first consider the expectations set by numerous other stories, and then examine the films independently, without reference to the source material.
If two characters do not have a pre-established relationship at the beginning of a story, they will likely not end up together until close to the end of the story after a great deal of will-they-won’t-they tension and flirting.
This same structure is utilised in the Harry Potter films, but not in a way that would give the audience a hint as to how the story will conclude.
The best way to examine the situation is film by film, noting any scenes that could be interpreted as romantic and what these scenes appear to foreshadow.
Why Romance in the Harry Potter Movies Doesn’t Work?
Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone
Predictably, Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone does little to set up any romance, as the main characters and actors portraying them are children at this point; romance is the furthest thing from their minds. However, it does establish some interactions between characters that will remain consistent throughout the series.
While Ron (Rupert Grint) and Harry (Daniel Radcliffe) become fast friends, Hermione (Emma Watson) is initially rejected as a friend.
Notably, the incident that initiates their friendship only occurs because Hermione overhears Ron saying unkind things about her, and Ron ultimately feels sorry for her and desires to rescue her.
Despite this, Ron and Hermione’s relationship remains tense for the majority of the remainder of the series. Harry meets Ginny (Bonnie Wright) at the beginning of the film, but she plays no further role in the plot.
Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets is the Title of the Third Harry Potter Novel
There is only one significant romance-related event in Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets: Harry saving Ginny’s life. Ginny was previously shown to have a crush on Harry, and this event is the most likely reason for their eventual union.
As the film progresses, however, other characters will demonstrate superior chemistry with Harry. In addition, The Chamber of Secrets contains a scene that exemplifies one of the most significant problems with the way romance is portrayed in films.
Ron defends Hermione when Malfoy (Tom Felton) calls her mud blood, just as he did in the books, demonstrating his continued concern for her.
Hermione, as opposed to Ron, explains to Harry and the audience what mud blood is, whereas Ron in the book is aware that the term is negative but does not know why. This minor adjustment encompasses all the adjustments they made to Ron.
He no longer serves as the audience’s guide to the wizarding world; instead, he provides comic relief with a few humorous lines.
His role has been assigned to Hermione, altering the group dynamic from one in which each character has their own strengths and weaknesses to one in which Harry and Hermione appear to have all the strengths and Ron serves only as comic relief.
Check out our article:- Does Steve Die in Stranger Things 4? Who is His Costume Designer?
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban’s Story
The tension between Ron and Hermione from the first book continues in Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, but this time Hermione fights back instead of fleeing. As they argue about their pets for the duration of the film, tensions between the two remain high.
The plot thread is abandoned as Harry and Hermione embark on their own adventure, despite the expectation of a positive moment in which the pair reconcile and strengthen their relationship. Even when Ron and Hermione are in conflict, they are typically in good standing.
Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets
Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets contains only one significant romance-related event: Harry saving Ginny’s life. Ginny had previously been shown to have a crush on Harry, and this event is the best reason for them to end up together.
However, as the film’s progress, other characters will demonstrate that they have better chemistry with Harry.
The Chamber of Secrets also contains a scene that exemplifies one of the most significant issues with the way romance is portrayed in films.
Ron defends Hermione when Malfoy (Tom Felton) refers to her as mud blood, just as he did in the books, demonstrating once again that he cares about her.
Hermione, as opposed to Ron, explains what mud blood is to Harry and the audience, whereas Ron in the book knows that the term is negative but not why.
This small modification encompasses all the modifications they made to Ron. He is no longer the audience’s guide to the wizarding world; instead, he serves as comic relief with a few lines played for laughs.
His role has been given to Hermione, altering the group dynamic from one in which each character has their own strengths and weaknesses to one in which Harry and Hermione appear to have all the strengths and Ron is only there for comic relief.
Ready to take the next step? Click The Link Below:-
- Is Vecna Stronger than The Mind Flayer? Stranger Things Character Update!
- Is Eddie on Blue Bloods Pregnant in Real Life? Blue Bloods Character Update!
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban.
In Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, the tension between Ron and Hermione from the first book continues, but this time Hermione fights back instead of fleeing.
Throughout the duration of the film, tensions remain high between the two as they argue about their pets.
The plot thread is abandoned as Harry and Hermione embark on their own adventure together, despite the fact that you would anticipate a wholesome moment in which the pair reconcile and strengthen their relationship.
Their moments alone occur more frequently as the film progresses, and even when Ron and Hermione are fighting, they are almost always in good standing.
Summary
The Harry Potter franchise has been criticized for its lack of satisfying love stories, but this can be explained by examining the films independently without reference to the source material.
Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets is the third Harry Potter novel, with only one significant romance-related event: Harry saving Ginny’s life.
Ron defends Hermione when Malfoy calls her mud blood, demonstrating his concern for her. Ron defends Hermione when Malfoy refers to her as mud blood, demonstrating his care for her.
Comments are closed.