My Life with The Walter Boys Season 1 Ending Explained and Recap

By Leora Marroquin On Aug 28, 2025

Netflix’s teen drama My Life with the Walter Boys delivered a season full of grief, romance, rivalry, and self-discovery. Adapted from Ali Novak’s beloved Wattpad novel, the 10-episode first season balanced heartfelt coming-of-age themes with the irresistible pull of a classic love triangle. But the finale left fans with plenty of questions about Jackie’s future—and her complicated feelings for the Walter brothers.

A Quick Recap of the Story

The series follows Jackie Howard (Nikki Rodriguez), a straight-A Manhattan teenager whose life changes overnight after losing her family in a tragic accident. She relocates to Silver Falls, Colorado, to live with her mother’s best friend Katherine Walter (Sarah Rafferty) and her husband George (Marc Blucas), who are raising ten kids on a ranch.

Amid grief and culture shock, Jackie clings to her dream of getting into Princeton—but finds herself pulled into a love triangle between two very different Walter brothers:

Alex (Ashby Gentry): The steady, bookish, and thoughtful choice.
Cole (Noah LaLonde): The brooding, impulsive, and passionate option.

The Love Triangle: Alex vs. Cole

Showrunner Melanie Halsall compared Jackie’s dynamic with the brothers to the iconic Stefan/Damon/Elena triangle in The Vampire Diaries.

With Alex, Jackie finds stability, friendship, and intellectual compatibility. Their bond represents the safe choice—a love that feels logical.
With Cole, the connection is chaotic but magnetic. Both have faced dreams cut short—Jackie through tragedy and Cole through a career-ending football injury. Their shared pain creates an undeniable pull, even if it risks heartbreak.

Throughout Season 1, Jackie struggles to reconcile these two sides of herself: the girl who wants control and order, and the one who craves freedom and passion.

How My Life with The Walter Boys Season 1 Ends

The finale dramatically shifts Jackie’s story.

Before leaving for rodeo training camp, Alex confesses his love for Jackie. She doesn’t say it back, signaling her uncertainty.
Later, Jackie learns that Cole secretly repaired her late mother’s teapot—a symbolic gesture of care and vulnerability. The moment leads to a heated kiss between Jackie and Cole.
Torn and unable to face either brother, Jackie leaves an apology note behind.
In the final moments, Jackie boards a flight back to New York with her uncle Richard and Danny, leaving both Alex and Cole heartbroken—and fans desperate for answers.

While Jackie doesn’t officially end things with Alex, her kiss with Cole sets the stage for an explosive Season 2.

Themes and Symbolism

The cellar scene with the teapot illustrates the depth of Jackie’s emotional struggle. Fixing the broken heirloom represents Cole’s hidden tenderness, contrasting with Alex’s steady declarations of love. Jackie’s inability to choose mirrors the show’s exploration of:

Grief and healing: How loss reshapes identity and relationships.
Cycles of love: The push-and-pull between stability and risk.
Coming of age: Jackie finding her own voice amidst family chaos.

Where Was It Filmed?

My Life with the Walter Boys was shot in Calgary, Alberta, doubling for Colorado’s wide-open ranch landscapes. Authentic rodeo culture shaped the show, with real ranch hands and wranglers helping the cast learn horseback riding and Western traditions.

What’s Next for Jackie and the Walter Boys?

Netflix has already confirmed Season 2, promising to explore the fallout of Jackie’s note, Alex’s heartbreak, and Cole’s growing role in her life. With Jackie returning to Silver Falls, the tension between the brothers is set to intensify.

As showrunner Melanie Halsall put it, Alex may be “the one Jackie should be with,” but Cole is “the one she can’t help herself with.” That conflict remains the emotional core of the series.

Final Thoughts

Season 1 of My Life with the Walter Boys ended not with neat closure, but with a cliffhanger fueled by grief, passion, and self-discovery. By the time Jackie chose to run back to New York, she proved one thing: this isn’t just a love triangle—it’s a story about finding who you are when your world is turned upside down.

What do you think Jackie’s real choice will be in Season 2—Alex or Cole? Share your thoughts in the comments and stay tuned to InvestRecords.com for more updates on Netflix’s biggest YA dramas.